The bicycle cure for University Circle's parking crisis

Posted in:

With the already-car-clogged University Circle area expected to add up to 10,000 jobs in the next decade, one wonders where the new workers will park and how they will commute in and out of the area. The current parking solution seems to be more big garages. As the Plain Dealer reported today, the Cleveland Clinic is starting construction on a 4,000-space garage costing $170 million ($42,500 per space!).

But what if University Circle institutions started encouraging their employees to bike to work? Many employees live within easy bike commuting distance in Cleveland or the surrounding Heights communities. If University Circle institutions worked with these communities and invested a portion of their parking budgets on bike facilities, the area could have a world-class bike system that could be maintained year-round. It could be a win-win strategy — reduced congestion and parking costs, healthier employees (this should be a health promotion program for the hospitals), and a more vibrant University Circle environment that accommodates new growth. See our vision for this, the Circle-Heights Bike Network.

November 14, 2006 - 5:09pm

Make University Circle more dense, walkable

Marc Lefkowitz Says:

Hard to argue with the comment that University Circle institutions need to do more to spur housing and create a dense, thriving village in University Circle. I was encouraged by the New York Times article on all of the redevelopment efforts going on there. Also, read Steven Litt's article where he talks to Cleveland Clinic CEO Toby Cosgrove—who considers the new parking garage a 'bitter pill'.

The Clinic needs to devote resources to more housing like the proposed Upper Chester and Beacon Place—why not offer a $10,000 voucher for 'campus' housing like Case is offering its employees? 

It will be easier to convince doctors and white-collar workers to live within walking distance of work once Cleveland gets its first taste of new mixed-use attractions on Euclid Avenue. Meanwhile, bike commuting for those living in Cleveland Heights makes sense—it should be part of the Clinic's health and wellness agenda if it isn't already.     

November 14, 2006 - 4:34pm

as a Case employee

curatorius Says:

who walks and takes the #821 Circulator to work, my money's also on transit -- and on more housing within walking distance to campus -- as the long-term answer, more so than bikes. Bikes require people to be somewhat physically fit, and many people - though assuredly not everyone - are unprepared to bike in the worst days of Cleveland winters.
Any funny that you mention the University Circle parking crisis, because I've just been sending out feelers to stakeholders about a transit village on Cedar where the Red Line RTA station fronts. At a UCI event last fall, designers showed a sketch of a vastly improved RTA station that could come about due to RTA and maybe federal money that's been headed this station's way for a while. While we're at it, why not have a few housing unit suitable to Case staff or graduate students, plus a touch of lunch/coffee retail, abutting a cleaned up intersection designed so that people could cross the street without being terrorized by cars? If this idea excites you, email me at curatorius@hotmail.com
But as far as bikes are concerned, if you're going to live at Cedar and Fairmount, the choice between walking and biking is 5 minutes versus 15 minutes, and for the price of that extra ten minutes you won't have to wipe off sweat or check for bike grease on your pant leg.

November 17, 2006 - 12:03pm

Transit, housing, as well as bikes

David Beach Says:

You're right that transit and increased housing density should be major parts of a comprehensive strategy to reduce automobile dependence. In my short post, I just addressed the bike issue because it's often left out of the discussion. University Circle and the surrounding Heights need a transportation demand strategy that involves many alternatives.

But I wouldn't discount the potential for bikes to take a big share of trips -- even in Cleveland weather. Weather is no excuse. Cities with comparable weather around the world have much greater bike use. It takes a change of culture -- and decent facilities (like showers at work) -- to make it happen.

November 14, 2006 - 4:06pm

Alternate commuting methods

Stephen Gross Says:

I certainly agree that the over-dependence on cars is a serious long-term problem. A few thoughts, though:

(1) The parking cost: Surprisingly, I crunched the numbers and the per-unit cost ($42,500 per space) is not unreasonable. The Clinic can make their investment back in ten years at a reasonable rate (see my blog for the full calculations).

(2) As for biking: I'm not convinced that biking is a good direction to push for. Well, maybe not the only one anyway. I've never understood how bike-to-work functions in our area, given (a) the hills and (b) the inclement weather. What are the practical solutions to those problems? In any case, my money is still on mass transit, especially expanded light rail. I've seen enough light rail in action (Baltimore and Portland OR) to see that it has advantages over buses & subways.

(3) Do you think that the Euclid Corridor, once complete, will help the situation?

--Steve (http://grossreport.blogspot.com)

November 17, 2006 - 12:15pm

Euclid Corridor effects

David Beach Says:

The new Euclid Corridor bus rapid transit service will certainly help elevate the status of transit in the University Circle area, and it will make it more pleasant to go downtown from University Circle. But I'm not sure how much it will help alter commuting patterns up and down from the surrounding Heights.

Parking garages could be profitable, depending on how much employee parking is subsidized (although I still find it astonishing that our society is willing to invest so much to park cars). But that doesn't consider the other negative impacts of ugliness of the urban dead zones they create and how they foster an unhealthy culture of auto dependence.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.