Banning Plastic Bags

Posted in:

I just read an article about some cities (notably San Francisco) that are taking the initiative to ban plastic bags in favor of the compostable variety. The motivation is mostly financial - cities spend millions each year to clean up bags and unclog drain pipes - but the environmental impact is of particular importance: these things never bio-degrade and we use over a billion gallons of oil each year to make them.

Is there any such effort on the table in this area?

February 5, 2008 - 5:41pm

Plastic bags: On the way out?

Marc Lefkowitz Says:

Michael,

Thanks for posting this. Even those of us who are using canvass bags have work to do; insisting every time we go to a store for one or two items and happen to be without our reusable bag that, no, really, we don't need a plastic bag.

I'm encouraged that Whole Foods is eliminating plastic bags from all of its stores starting this EarthDay. It sends a strong message, and it encourages their shoppers to buy reusable bags which they hopefully will end up using in other stores, spreading the message that way.

PD columnist Connie Schultz wrote about personally quitting plastic bags this week. She writes:

When I started writing this column, there were 47,055,984,738 reasons to stop using plastic bags. That was the number of bags consumed so far in the world this year, according to the Web site, reusablebags.com.

I thought it was enough that I reused the plastic bags, but they still end up in the trash. The site lists all kinds of harrowing statistics, including this one: Hundreds of thousands of sea turtles, whales and other marine life die every year after eating discarded plastic bags they mistake for food.

The wake up call for me was seeing the LA Times' Pulitzer Prize winning series Altered Oceans. The online content is amazing, including video and photos of scenes like Midway Island in the Pacific Ocean where a patch of plastic debris twice the size of Texas washes up.

We need an effort that encourages more retailers to ban plastic bags. Or we can consider a tax on plastic bags as they did in Ireland (see Susan's comment above). We can begin by thinking through how to implement a ban or tax, maybe at the county level, and how do we encourage retailers (by researching how it works in Ireland and San Francisco and coming up with a transition strategy, I think). We'll collect ideas on how to do this here.

 

February 19, 2008 - 1:07pm

Heartening Words

Michael Lehto Says:

These are good comments, to be sure. It seems like the momentum is building for this, albeit at a very slow pace. Whole Foods' decision to eliminate plastic bags altogether is a huge step.

Now, for those markets and stores that have switched to reusable bags, we need to push for them to be an inexpensive item. A reusable bag need not be a "boutique" item (I'm thinking of the $5 bags I see in some places). They do not necessarily have to be made of hemp, organic cotton, or some other such material. The point is to have a bag that you use again and again. Heck, I've made a few of my own... they don't win me any style points at the top-notch markets, but they sure do work.

February 22, 2008 - 2:37pm

plasTAX

John McGovern Says:

Hey Michael:

Good point on affordability, which is especially important during the transition away from disposable plastic bags. Once we make it through the transition period, focus should be put on more sustainable materials.
On that note, Dave's (cleveland based grocery chain) has re-usable plastic/canvas bags for $1. Also, the Save-A-Lot chain charges $0.10 for bags, which are made of a heavier weight plastic.

I agree with Susan that this would be a revenue generator; one that is no more biased against lower income populations than the Keno proposal.

Does anyone know much about Chicago's recent tax on bottled water?

February 25, 2008 - 3:12pm

Chicago Bottled Water Tax

Michael Lehto Says:

That's a good example, John - I just looked that up (found a short article here) and saw that Chicago imposed a 10 cent tax on bottled water. Plastic bags are obviously much cheaper and lower in plastic content than bottles, but it would be interesting to consider this kind of incentive to move away from plastic bag usage.

January 29, 2009 - 8:19pm

Toronto Goes Back to the Tap

Susan Miller Says:

Toronto Goes Back to the Tap

"Increasingly across Canada, municipal leaders are showing that there is a strong political will for reinvestments in public water services. However, access to municipal drinking water is dwindling with new buildings constructed without water fountains and older ones decommissioning existing fountains. Now is the time to issue strong calls to all levels of government for greater public access to free potable water and a wholesale reinvestment in water infrastructure and services."

While here in the US legislators drink bottled water even as they discuss the Tri-state Water Wars between Georgia, Alabama and Florida. Sheesh. America has a drinking problem

"Reduce/Reuse/Recycle. Buying these and then throwing the plastic away is not wasteful, it’s shameful. There is no ‘away’, there are only large holes dug into the earth, that we wistfully and ironically call ‘landfills’. It takes four liters of water to produce a one liter plastic bottle and every time you bury one in the ground, another one gets made.

"Recycling the bottle,” I went on to say, “is a better idea, so please use our recycling containers as you leave. I’m going to take this one home and refill it nine or ten times before recycling, which is the ‘Reuse’ part of the three ‘R’ equation. ‘Reduction’, however, is where we all need to get to, and soon, because one out of every five people on earth does not have clean drinking water. Two out of every five people do not have access to basic sanitation. The resulting illnesses cause the deaths of over 5 million people each year, and they are mostly children.”

 

February 21, 2008 - 2:36am

holiday shopping bags

Susan Miller Says:

When friends and family who are avid readers asked for new book releases I found myself walking out of a bookstore toting a quite sturdy plastic bag of books. Since then for two years it has served as a handy grocery sack (as they are called in my native American south). Thank you Barnes and Noble. I don't see this losing strength for sometime to come. In my family, the treasured and now tattered L.L. Bean canvas bags have been passed down through the generations, too, like my first pair of jeans which were handed down to me from my brother (battery acid holes and all). Also posted here sometime ago is the Japanese alternative, the furoshiki.

February 6, 2008 - 1:45pm

reuseable bags

Susan Miller Says:

Reusable bags are fashionable. reuseablebags.com

February 10, 2008 - 11:19am

plastic bag problem in the local news

John McGovern Says:

Canton Repository
Monday, February 4, 2008
BY Robert Wang
REPOSITORY STAFF WRITER

http://www.cantonrep.com/index.php?ID=398005&Category=9&fromSearch=yes&subCategoryID=0

February 11, 2008 - 11:37am

plastax instead of Keno

Susan Miller Says:

Maybe this should be advanced to Governor Strickland's desk instead of going for a local initiative? If there was a reductionist plastax who would want that "Oh duh, I forgot to bring my own bag" money?

October 15, 2007 - 11:48am

tax for environment

Susan Miller Says:

I wrote about this a year ago when the arts tax was out there for consideration. It happens in Ireland to great success. Frankly, I think arts money might come from imported cheese and wine, but a plastax makes a lot of sense. We can all decide to forgo the tax by bringing our own bags (reuse) and this does not impinge on the poor as much an imposed sales tax increase. Here's more on the subject. We are a bit behind the curve in NEO as you know, Michael. We have yet to have a sewer district that will be able to ask for more money from vendors with large parking lots as a stormwater utility because it has done such a poor job of managing the money and waste it currently stewards. However, other cities have stormwater utilities and residents can lower their sewer bills by holding stormwater on their property reducing the volume for the utility. Not in NEO. We are strapped to the ticking bomb of what our "leaders" determine is a good solution. We individually can remember to reuse bags or carry backpacks or canvas bags, but I wouldn't hold your breath for a progressive tax like this one in our region. Our leaders prefer the pre-New Deal methods. Best bet is to suggest it to taxin' Tim Hagan. He seems to be the  Numero Uno tax man in our region. I'm sure the county would like to have all the good suggestions they can get. They certainly need the cash. It won't be an environmental cause, but you could help them sell it that way. Here ya go Tim, a way to green your tax profile!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.